← Second Look · my essays
Fintech & digital banking

Having a customer is not the same as being their first choice

An account opens a relationship. Everyday use tells us what that relationship actually means.

Your perspective ↓Stay with these essays ↓
Listen to this essay

Read aloud using an English voice on your device.

Voice availability depends on your device and browser.

Someone has an account with our bank, keeps a balance and may even have borrowed from us. Our report calls them a customer. Yet when they need to send money to family, pay a bill or work out what they can spend before payday, they go somewhere else.

Adding another feature will not necessarily close that gap. First, I want to understand the role we have in their financial life.

An account is not an everyday relationship

A relationship built around borrowing does not automatically become a relationship around managing money. A customer can be satisfied and still never think of us for an ordinary task. Sometimes the problem is the role we occupy in their mind, rather than poor service.

If we confuse those relationships, our growth plan starts from the wrong premise. We count accounts but expect everyday behaviour. We invest in installations and logins while trying to build repeated preference.

Everyday banking begins with a recurring situation in a customer's life, not a catalogue of services.

One simple service, two different questions

Consider a mobile top-up. As a standalone service, the job is a successful purchase, a short journey and sound economics. As part of an everyday relationship, I also ask: will the customer choose us next time? Will they buy for someone else here? Does the experience build confidence for the next task?

This is a hypothetical example. A top-up is not evidence of a deep relationship, and buying for another person does not make that recipient a new banking customer. But defining the problem differently changes both the experiment and its measures.

Look for behaviour, then interpret it carefully

Next-cycle repeat use, the interval between purchases and movement into a related everyday need can be useful signals. Each needs a precise definition, a comparison group and the real cost of delivering the service. A higher number is not automatically a better result.

Four questions before expanding

When does the need arise? Why would someone leave their familiar method? What makes returning worthwhile after the first use? Which observable behaviour would suggest that a relationship is forming?

Build a small loop before a large product

The temptation is to build an extensive everyday banking product. I would rather test one small but complete loop: a real need, a clear reason to choose us, a reliable experience and a natural reason to return.

If that loop fails, ten more services may make the diagnosis harder. If it works, we have evidence for the next step. If we removed the incentive tomorrow, what reason to return would remain?

Keep the thought going

That is how I see it. Your experience may reveal another part of the problem.

Add your perspective ↓

Follow Second Look in your RSS reader ↗

Your perspective

What does your experience add?

Comments are reviewed before publication. Your email address will stay private.

Add your perspective

More to think about

Explore Second Look

What are you thinking about?