← Second Look · my essays
Customers & business

When a strong position makes it harder to be chosen

Trust built around one role does not automatically carry into a neighbouring need.

Your perspective ↓Stay with these essays ↓
Listen to this essay

Read aloud using an English voice on your device.

Voice availability depends on your device and browser.

A business works for years to become known for one service, and succeeds. It adds a related service and expects its existing reputation to open the door. The customer goes elsewhere. They may be perfectly satisfied. They simply did not think of this business.

Trusted to do what?

We often treat trust as a general asset. A customer may attach it to a specific role: one place for a good price, another for advice, one for urgent tasks and another for an important choice.

Inside the organisation, the services sit next to each other. Outside it, customers may put them in different categories. That gap can leave us surprised by weak adoption before we have understood why we are chosen at all.

How can a strong position become a boundary?

A firmly established role can leave a new need outside the frame. The customer does not have to reject us. Our name only needs to be absent when that need arises. This is a possible mechanism to investigate, not a universal explanation for unsuccessful expansion.

Before changing the brand or the slogan, distinguish the problems. Does the customer know the service exists? Believe we can deliver it? Find it appropriate? Or remember us at the right moment? Each calls for a different response.

A better research question

Instead of asking whether someone would like to get an additional service from us, ask what happened the last time they had that need: which options came to mind, and what did they actually do? A behavioural account is more useful than polite agreement.

We do not have to be the choice for everything

Sometimes expanding our role is not the right answer. The service may not fit our operating capabilities or economics. A clear position can be worth more than a broad claim unsupported by the experience.

The same applies to us as leaders. Being the right person in one situation does not make us the right choice in every situation. Absence from some shortlists is not, by itself, evidence of inability.

The task is to know where to widen the role, and where to keep its boundaries with confidence.

Keep the thought going

That is how I see it. Your experience may reveal another part of the problem.

Add your perspective ↓

Follow Second Look in your RSS reader ↗

Your perspective

What does your experience add?

Comments are reviewed before publication. Your email address will stay private.

Add your perspective

More to think about

Explore Second Look

What are you thinking about?