When the team’s behaviour is a rational response to the organisation’s rules
Before blaming a culture or a person, follow the incentives, constraints and consequences around one specific behaviour.
Listen to this essay
Read aloud using an English voice on your device.
Voice availability depends on your device and browser.
We ask departments to collaborate, but reward them only for their own results. We ask managers to decide, then respond to their first mistake with more approval layers. Afterwards we wonder why collaboration is rare and decisions keep moving upwards.
The official message is not the whole message
People respond to more than the values on the wall. They notice repeated patterns: who is promoted, which errors are tolerated, what gets rewarded and where responsibility stops.
These are not the only causes of behaviour. Individual ability, team history and external conditions also matter. But overlooking the rules can lead us to treat a structural problem with individual training.
Follow one behaviour through the system
Instead of beginning with “our culture is broken”, choose something observable. Why do managers escalate ordinary decisions? Examine recent instances: what information was available, what authority did they have and what happened the last time they decided independently?
A simple observation record
Specific behaviour → situation → relevant rule or constraint → current consequence → a small change we can test. This sequence produces a hypothesis; it does not prove causation. Look for counterexamples and competing explanations.
Make a small change with a clear observation
If unclear authority is the suspected cause, delegate a bounded class of decisions with explicit limits and an exception route. Observe the result. If behaviour does not change, revisit the hypothesis: skill, genuine risk or earlier experiences may be more important.
Changing everything at once makes it harder to understand any one effect. A limited experiment at least makes the source of learning more visible.
Individual responsibility remains
Seeing the structure does not erase responsibility. It can make expectations fairer and interventions more effective. Sometimes a rule needs changing, sometimes a capability needs building and sometimes an individual performance decision is necessary.
When the environment rewards one behaviour and makes another costly, we should not expect people to fight its logic every day.
That is how I see it. Your experience may reveal another part of the problem.
Add your perspective ↓
What does your experience add?
Comments are reviewed before publication. Your email address will stay private.