← Second Look · my essays
Leadership & change

A new leader, but the same old rules?

A transformation mandate means little unless the organisation accepts what changing the outcome will cost.

Your perspective ↓Stay with these essays ↓
Listen to this essay

Read aloud using an English voice on your device.

Voice availability depends on your device and browser.

A company wants to transform. It recruits a leader with a strong record, energy and serious ideas. Months later, the familiar requests return: hiring is difficult, budgets arrive late, departments do not align and decisions stall across layers.

The person may have been the wrong appointment. Before settling on that answer, I would test another possibility: the organisation wanted a new result without changing the rules that produce the existing one.

Transformation cannot be delegated to one person alone

A leader can clarify the problem, propose changes and move their team forward. But when change depends on other departments' authority, capital allocation or an unresolved conflict, more effort at that leader's level is not enough.

This does not make bottom-up action pointless. Small experiments can create evidence and shift direction. The mistake is placing an organisation-wide promise on narrowly bounded authority.

Four agreements beyond the job description

Which decisions belong to the role? Which resources will be available, and when? Who resolves conflicts between departments? Which existing rules can be reconsidered?

Authority becomes real at the first conflict

“You have full authority” is not a sufficient answer. Authority is real when it can be used in an important disagreement. If every change must travel through the process that was supposed to change, the commitment needs another look.

The new leader still has responsibilities. They should explain the constraint precisely: which decision is blocked, where, and by whom? “The organisation is not supportive” is not a sufficient diagnosis.

Perhaps the organisation has not decided yet

A chief executive may genuinely be unsure how far change can go, and recruit someone to find out. That can be sensible if it is described honestly: a bounded discovery and testing phase, with clear measures.

The trouble starts when a limited-commitment experiment is called transformation, and the new arrival is judged against a result whose cost the organisation has not accepted.

Watch the first costly decision

I learn more from the first moment when an old priority must give way, money must move or another leader must change their approach than from the introduction meeting.

That is where we begin to see whether the organisation wants change, or wants someone to prove that everything else can stay the same.

Keep the thought going

That is how I see it. Your experience may reveal another part of the problem.

Add your perspective ↓

Follow Second Look in your RSS reader ↗

Your perspective

What does your experience add?

Comments are reviewed before publication. Your email address will stay private.

Add your perspective

More to think about

Explore Second Look

What are you thinking about?