Evidence, experience and values: three questions before a decision
These are complementary ways to examine a decision, not labels for different kinds of leader.
Listen to this essay
Read aloud using an English voice on your device.
Voice availability depends on your device and browser.
We sometimes discuss decisions as if we must choose between data, intuition and values. A management decision can require evidence, experience and a boundary we are unwilling to cross at the same time.
What do we need the evidence to tell us?
First, ask what can be measured and what remains unknown. Data does not necessarily improve a decision if the problem is poorly defined or the data's limitations are misunderstood. A precise number can rest on an inappropriate assumption.
For a financial service, we may know the usage rate without knowing why people use it. Those are different kinds of knowledge; one does not replace the other.
Where does experience help?
Experience can reveal a pattern or inconsistency before a formal report does. Familiarity can also mislead us. How similar is this situation to the earlier one, and what is different this time?
When conditions are new, the cost of error is high or testing is possible, turn the initial feeling into a hypothesis. Look for evidence that could support it and evidence that could contradict it.
What boundaries do values establish?
Some options may generate revenue but conflict with our commitments to customers or a legal obligation. Values should not be reduced to an arbitrary score beside profit. Sometimes they define which options are acceptable in the first place.
“It does not fit our values” still needs an explanation. Otherwise it can become a respectable cover for personal preference.
Three complementary questions
What evidence supports or weakens the choice? Which experience is relevant, and where might the analogy fail? Which commitment or boundary rules out an option before we compare its returns?
Open up the decision, rather than categorising the person
These questions are not a personality test. One leader can take all three seriously in one decision and overlook one in the next.
The useful result is a better team conversation: what can we see, what are we assuming and which boundary needs to be made clearer?
That is how I see it. Your experience may reveal another part of the problem.
Add your perspective ↓
What does your experience add?
Comments are reviewed before publication. Your email address will stay private.