A good outcome does not tell us whether the decision was good
Accountability should help us distinguish judgement, execution and luck.
Listen to this essay
Read aloud using an English voice on your device.
Voice availability depends on your device and browser.
Two leaders make a decision. One works with clear assumptions and reasonable investigation, then gets a poor outcome. The other proceeds without enough examination and gets a good one. Can those outcomes alone tell us who made the better decision?
Results matter. So does the explanation.
Looking at the process should not become a way to avoid responsibility for results. Leaders should be accountable. Accountability supports learning when we can distinguish the effects of the decision, its execution and events outside our control.
Otherwise we may repeat a risky choice that happened to work, or abandon a defensible decision because it failed once.
Leave a trace of the thinking before the result arrives
Before an important decision, I suggest a short note. What is the problem? What are the alternatives? What do we know? Which assumption, if wrong, would change the choice? When will we look again?
Its value is that we cannot quietly rewrite the story to fit the outcome. The point is not another heavy document for the meeting.
A compact decision record
Record the choice and the alternative set aside; the main reason and uncertainty; an observable expectation with a time frame; a signal for reconsideration; the owner of execution and the review date.
A review is not a trial
Before asking who made a mistake, ask which assumption did not hold. Was the problem information, interpretation or execution? Individual responsibility becomes more precise after that distinction is clear.
If every review becomes personal defence, the decision record will eventually become theatre. People will write what causes the least trouble rather than what actually guided the choice.
What can improve?
This practice cannot guarantee correct decisions. It makes questions and assumptions visible. Over time, we can see where confidence exceeded evidence, which warnings we missed and when weak execution was mistaken for poor judgement.
The outcome still matters. It is simply no longer the only thing we learn from.
That is how I see it. Your experience may reveal another part of the problem.
Add your perspective ↓
What does your experience add?
Comments are reviewed before publication. Your email address will stay private.